The Taller the Ladder, the Tougher the Climb?: Essays on the Impact of Income Inequality on Intergenerational Mobility

PublicationBook
Erik Liss

Abstract

The study of income inequality has a rich history within economics and various social sciences. More recently, a growing body of literature has examined intergenerational income mobility to understand not only equality of opportunities but also whether the labor market allocation successfully utilizes the potential abilities from all social strata. This dissertation explores the intricate relationship between income inequality and intergenerational mobility through three distinct research articles.

If we envision the income distribution as a ladder, income inequality can be likened to the relative distance between the ladder’s rungs, where greater inequality corresponds to a more stretched-out ladder. Income mobility, on the other hand, is a much more multifaceted concept. The most common way of measuring it is relative mobility, which tries to quantify the mobility between the rungs of the ladder, where an upward jump for one born poor necessarily implies a downward shift for one born richer.

Article 1 studies how relative mobility is affected by income inequality across regions within Sweden. If there are substantial income differences across regions within countries that persist across generations, this will contribute to a more stretched-out ladder, potentially making mobility more difficult. The study demonstrates that these regional income disparities persist across generations, resulting in decreased income mobility. The article then proceeds to examine whether migration patterns between richer and poorer regions mitigate or exacerbate this effect.

In contrast to relative mobility, absolute mobility measures if children end up being better off in the standard of living compared to their parents, regardless of whether they manage to climb to a higher rung on the ladder compared to their parents. Article 2 delves into examining the trend in absolute income mobility for Sweden, measured as the percentage of children earning more than their parents. The novel decomposition method reveals that Sweden has a high level of absolute mobility mainly due to the low level of income inequality.

Article 3 explores the potential of public education to mitigate inequities by examining the causal effects of a 1989 Swedish teacher strike that caused school closures. The article reveals that the strike had both negative short-run effects, measured as student results, and long-run effects, measured as earnings, and the effects were larger for individuals from low-income backgrounds.

In summary, this dissertation provides both empirical and methodological contributions to the intricate relationship between inequality and mobility.

Liss, E. (2024). The Taller the Ladder, the Tougher the Climb?: Essays on the Impact of Income Inequality on Intergenerational Mobility. Linköping University Electronic Press.


Similar content

Absolute income mobility and the effect of parent generation inequality: An extended decomposition approach
Article (with peer review)Publication
Liss, E., Korpi, M., & Wennberg, K.
Publication year

2023

Published in

European Economic Review, 152, 104359.

Abstract

We use full-population data to study trends in intergenerational absolute income mobility, measured as the ratio of children earning more than their parents, for 11 Swedish cohorts born 1972-1983. Absolute mobility during this period increases from 72% to 84% for men and from 76% to 86% for women-higher figures than in most other countries studied. To explain these results, we outline a novel decomposition strategy that accounts for cohort variation in parent-generation income inequality. All else equal, if income inequality is higher in the parent generation, more economic growth is required to achieve any given level of absolute mobility. We discuss implications for comparative research in intergenerational income mobility.

Ratio Working Paper No. 325: The American Dream Lives in Sweden: Trends in intergenerational absolute income mobility
Working paperPublication
Liss, E., Korpi, M. & Wennberg, K.
Publication year

2019

Published in

Ratio Working Paper

Abstract

Despite a sizeable literature on relative income mobility across generations, there is a dearth of studies of absolute mobility across generations, i.e. whether current generations earn more or less than their parents did at the same age, as well as how to explain the level of absolute mobility. We use individual micro data to study the trend in intergenerational absolute income mobility measured as the share of sons and daughters earning more than their fathers and mothers, respectively, for eleven Swedish birth cohorts between 1970 and 1980. We find that absolute mobility in Sweden significantly exceeds that of the United States and is largely on par with Canada. The rate of absolute mobility for women exceeds that of men throughout the study period, however the trend has been stronger for men. Using an augmented decomposition model which supplements standard models by accounting for differences in the income distribution of every birth cohort’s parent generation, we find that heterogeneity in the parent income distribution strongly determines how much economic growth contributes to absolute mobility across birth cohorts. If income inequality is high in the parent generation, more growth is required if children that move downward in the relative income distribution are to earn more than their parents.

Show more