Ratio logo white

Ratio is an interdisciplinary research institute, with a research focus on the conditions of business and enterprise.

08-441 59 00info@ratio.se

802002-5212

Sveavägen 59 4trp

11359 Stockholm

Bankgiro: 512-6578

PublicationsSeminarsPeople

Popular

News archive
Publications
Seminars
People
Start
About
Contact us
Labour market research
Competitiveness research
Climate and environmental research
Swedish flag iconPå svenska
PublicationWorking paper

Working Paper No. 53. How Politically Diverse Are the Social Sciences and Humanities? Survey Evidence from Six Fields

Download PDF

Abstract

In Spring 2003, a large-scale survey of American academics was conducted using academic association membership lists from six fields: Anthropology, Economics, History, Philosophy (political and legal), Political Science, and Sociology. This paper focuses on one question: To which political party have the candidates you’ve voted for in the past ten years mostly belonged? The question was answered by 96.4 percent of academic respondents. The results show that the faculty is heavily skewed towards voting Democratic. The most lopsided fields surveyed are Anthropology with a D to R ratio of 30.2 to 1, and Sociology with 28.0 to 1. The least lopsided is Economics with 3.0 to 1. After Economics, the least lopsided is Political Science with 6.7 to 1. The average of the six ratios by field is about 15 to 1. Our analysis and related research suggest that for the the social sciences and humanities overall, a “one-big-pool” ratio of 7 to 1 is a safe lower-bound estimate, and 8 to 1 or 9 to 1 are reasonable point estimates. Thus, the social sciences and humanities are dominated by Democrats. There is little ideological diversity. We discuss Stephen Balch’s “property rights” proposal to help remedy the situation.

Related content: Political Diversity in Six Disciplines

Klein, D. & Stern, C. (2004). How Politically Diverse Are the Social Sciences and Humanities? Survey Evidence from Six Fields. Ratio Working Paper No. 53.

Details

Author
Klein, D. & Stern, C.
Publication year
2004
Published in

Political Diversity in Six Disciplines

Related

  • Bild av Charlotta Stern, medarbetare på Ratio
    Professor & CEO

    Charlotta Stern

    +46761855817charlotta.stern@ratio.se
  • Associate Researcher

    Daniel Klein

    +17039931156dklein@gmu.edu

Similar content

Reports

Hur kan trösklarna in på den svenska arbetsmarknaden sänkas?

Stern, L. & Hamilton, E.
Download

Publication year

2026

Published in

Ratios arbetsmarknadsserie

Abstract

This report examines why people with weak labour market positions can face prolonged unemployment in Sweden despite employers’ recruitment difficulties. It argues that the small number of jobs with low entry requirements is one contributing factor. The authors compare three ways to expand such jobs: agreements between the state and social partners, collective agreements that allow simpler roles, and policy measures such as Germany’s mini-jobs. The German case suggests that simple rules can help schemes reach scale, while also showing risks of labour market segmentation and limited progression, particularly for women and older workers. The report also considers redesigning tasks within organisations. Its conclusion is that more jobs with lower entry barriers may complement education and active labour market measures, but require trade-offs between inclusion, working conditions and institutional design.

Book

Sociology and Classical Liberalism in Dialogue. Freedom is Something We Do Together

Rojas, F. & Stern, C.

Publication year

2024

Published in

Lexington Books.

Abstract

The motivation for Sociology and Classical Liberalism in Dialogue: Freedom is Something We Do Together is based on two observations: first, sociology as a field is populated with scholars on the left and second, (few but still) classical liberals and libertarian scholars are found in neighboring social science fields, such as economics, political science, and political philosophy. Can scholarship benefit if sociology and classical liberal ideas are in dialogue? To answer the question, the book gathers sociologists, criminologists, demographers, and political scientists that care about classical liberal ideas, or are willing to engage their sociological thinking with classical liberal ideas. Not all authors would identify themselves as classical liberals. These contributors discuss sociological topics through the lens of classical liberalism, asking how issues such as class, gender, or race relations can be viewed with a different perspective. Chapters also delve into the intersection of sociology and classical liberalism, exploring where viewpoints conflict and where they align.

Article (with peer review)

Managers on balancing employment protection and what’s good for the company: Intended and unintended consequences of a semi-coercive institution

Stern, C., & Weidenstedt, L.

Publication year

2022

Published in

Economic and Industrial Democracy.

Abstract

Sweden’s institutionalized employment protection legislation, ‘LAS’, is interesting theoretically because parts of it are semi-coercive. The semi-coerciveness makes it possible for firms and unions under collective agreements to negotiate departures from the law. Thus, the law is more flexible than the legal text suggests. The present study explores intended and unintended consequences of LAS as experienced by managers of smaller manufacturing companies. The results suggest that managers support the idea of employment protection in principle but face a difficult balancing act in dealing with LAS. From their point of view, the legislation’s institutional legitimacy is low, producing local cultures of hypocrisy and pretense. The article gives insights into how institutions aimed at specific, intended behavior sometimes end up producing unintended consequences fostering the opposite.

The article in total can be read here.

Show more